top of page
  • Writer's pictureDeallink

Methods and criteria for evaluating a company during an M&A

Assessing the value of a company is essential in Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A) transactions. It is a complex process that involves analyzing various financial, strategic and operational factors to determine the fair price a buyer should pay for a target company.

Valuation methods

One of the most widely used methods for assessing the value of a company during M&A is Discounted Cash Flow Analysis (DCF). This approach involves projecting the target company's future cash flows and then discounting them to present value using an appropriate discount rate.

DCF is highly regarded for its ability to take into account the long-term perspective and risks associated with the investment.

To carry out a DCF analysis, valuers usually start by estimating the target company's revenue, expense and capital investment projections. They then calculate the free cash flow, which is the money available to shareholders after all operating expenses and investments.

The next step involves selecting an appropriate discount rate, which reflects the risk of the investment. Finally, the future cash flows are discounted to present value, and the sum of these values represents the estimated value of the company.

Market comparables

Another fundamental method is the analysis of market comparables. In this method, the target company is compared to other similar companies that are already publicly traded or have recently been acquired in similar transactions. Valuators consider financial multiples such as P/E (Price/Earnings), EV/EBITDA (Enterprise Value/EBITDA), and other relevant indicators.

Market comparables analysis helps evaluate the target company in relation to its sector and market trends. It can also offer additional validation of the results obtained through other methods. However, it is important to ensure that the companies used as benchmarks are truly comparable in terms of size, operations and risk.

Equity value

The equity value is the net book value of the company and represents the difference between its assets and liabilities. This method is most appropriate for companies with significant tangible assets, such as property, factories or stock.

This is a simple and straightforward metric, but it may not adequately reflect the real value of a company if its assets are undervalued or if there are significant intangible assets, such as trademarks or intellectual property.

Valuation criteria

One of the most important criteria for assessing the value of a company during M&A is its financial performance. This includes historical revenue, profitability, growth and profit margins. Buyers generally look for companies with a solid track record of growth and consistent profitability.

In addition, the quality of the company's assets and liabilities, as well as the efficiency of its financial operations, are key criteria. Buyers want to understand the financial health of the target company and how it aligns with their strategic objectives.


Synergies represent the expected benefits of the M&A transaction, which may include cost savings, increased revenue, access to new markets or operational improvements. Assessing potential synergies is essential to determining the value of a target company. The greater the expected synergies, the higher the price a buyer may be willing to pay.

It is also important to be realistic when assessing synergies, as they are often difficult to achieve in practice. A careful analysis of the operations and strategies of the two companies involved in the transaction is necessary to identify and quantify synergies accurately.

Risks and contingencies

Assessing risks and contingencies is another critical criterion. Buyers want to understand all the potential risks that could affect the target company's future performance. This includes operational, legal, regulatory and financial risks.

It is important to carry out thorough due diligence to identify all possible problems and contingencies, which may involve reviewing contracts, pending litigation, labor issues and other factors that could impact the company in the future. Careful risk assessment allows buyers to make informed decisions about the price and terms of the transaction.

The importance of due diligence

Due diligence is a thorough investigation process that buyers carry out to gain a complete understanding of the target company. Due diligence covers financial, legal, operational and strategic aspects of the company and is essential for making informed decisions.

During this process, buyers review the target company's financial records, including financial statements, audit history, accounts receivable and payable, among other documents. They also take a close look at the company's assets and liabilities, identifying any discrepancies or financial concerns.

In addition, legal due diligence involves reviewing contracts, supplier agreements, pending litigation, intellectual property and other legal issues that may affect the company. Any legal issues discovered during this process can have an impact on the price and conditions of the transaction.

Operational due diligence focuses on the company's day-to-day operations, identifying operational efficiencies and inefficiencies, which helps buyers better understand how the company works and identify opportunities for improvement.

Finally, strategic due diligence involves assessing the target company's business strategy, market positioning and growth potential. Buyers seek to understand how the company fits into their overall strategy and how it can add value to their organization.

Challenges in valuing companies during M&A

Valuing companies during M&A can be a challenging task due to several factors. Some of the main challenges include:

  1. Complexity of the transactions: Many M&A transactions involve companies with complex operations and intricate capital structures, which makes valuation more challenging as a wide range of variables need to be considered.

  2. Future uncertainty: Predicting the future performance of a target company can be uncertain, especially in volatile or rapidly evolving sectors. Buyers need to make informed assumptions about the future, which can be risky.

  3. Valuing intangible assets: In many industries, intangible assets such as trademarks, patents and software play a crucial role in a company's value. Valuing these assets accurately can be a challenge.

  4. Confirmation bias: Buyers can be susceptible to confirmation bias, where they look for information that confirms their preconceptions about the value of the target company. This can lead to biased assessments.

  5. It is essential that buyers conduct a careful and objective analysis in order to make informed decisions and ensure that the price and terms of the transaction are fair for both parties involved.

  6. Economic cycles: Global and local economic conditions can have a significant impact on the value of a company. Changes in the economic environment can make performance forecasts more challenging.

  7. Assessing the value of a company during M&A is a complex process that involves the application of rigorous methods and criteria.



bottom of page